Religion and the 2026 Midterms: Polarization and Pursuing the Common Good

Image of a roll of I Voted stickers sandwiched between a wooden rosary and a wooden cross

A Panel Discussion with 

David Crary, Associated Press
Melissa Deckman,
 Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI)
Michele Dunne,
Franciscan Action Network

Moderated by: David T. Buckley, Boisi Center Director

Date: Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Time: 5 - 6:30pm
Location: Gasson Hall 100

What new about religion role on the 2026 campaign trail? And what can this election teach us about faith future in America divided democracy? Join a distinguished panel for insights drawn from polling, journalism, and grassroots practitioners organizing parishes to strengthen elections. 

headshot of David Crary

David Crary has been a reporter, editor and bureau chief with The Associated Press since 1976. Since mid-2021, he has been news director of AP's Global Religion Team. Crary joined the AP in Mississippi, later worked in Colorado and on the AP's international desk in New York, then covered East Africa and Southern Africa from 1985-1990 from bases in Kenya and South Africa. His assignments in Africa included the Ethiopian famine, the uprising against apartheid and Nelson Mandela's release from prison. From 1990-95, he was news editor at AP's Paris bureau, while serving eight stints in Sarajevo covering the war in Bosnia. He was named bureau chief in Toronto in 1995 and transferred to New York in 1999, where for 22 years he was a national writer primarily covering volatile social issues such as abortion, LGBTQ rights, and child welfare. 

headshot of Melissa Deckman

Melissa Deckman is CEO of Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) and a nationally recognized political scientist whose work examines how gender, religion, and age shape Americans' political attitudes and behavior. 

Deckman is the author of The Politics of Gen Z, which tells the story of how America's youngest generation is engaging with politics, and the deepening gender divide reshaping its views. She also wrote Tea Party Women, which explores the role of women in conservative politics. Her first book, School Board Battles: The Christian Right in Local Politics, won the American Political Science Association's Hubert Morken Award for the best book on religion and politics. 

A sought-after expert, Deckman has shared her research and commentary in The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Wall Street Journal, CNN, Politico, The Hill, Axios, and Newsweek, among other outlets. She also writes regularly for PRRI's Substack. Before becoming PRRI's CEO, she was the Louis L. Goldstein Professor of Public Affairs at Washington College. 

Deckman earned her Ph.D. in political science from American University and her bachelor's degree in political science from St. Mary's College of Maryland. 

headshot of Michele Dunne

Michele Dunne OFS is a professed Secular Franciscan and is the executive director of the Franciscan Action Network (FAN). Before coming to FAN, her career focused on the Middle East and U.S. foreign policy. From 2006 until 2021, she headed programs focused on peace, human rights, and democracy in the Middle East at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace and the Atlantic Council. Before that, she served for nearly 20 years in the U.S. Department of State, including assignments in Jerusalem and Cairo. She holds a Ph.D. from Georgetown University and lives in Washington DC with her husband.

Antisemitism and Islamophobia on the Campaign Trail

Crary, David. œMuslim Americans Push Back as Republican Politicians Stoke Anti-Sharia Rhetoric Ahead of Election.� AP News, September 25, 2026.

Crary, David. œAnti-Defamation League Says Anger at Israel Is Now the Driving Force Behind Antisemitism in the US.� The Associated Press, April 24, 2025.

Lajevardi, Nazita, Kassra Oskooii, Muniba Saleem, and Meagan Docherty. œIn the Shadow of September 11: The Roots and Ramifications of Anti-Muslim Attitudes in the United States.� Political Psychology 45, suppl. 1 (2024): 87“118. 

Lewis, Jacob S. œConspiracy and Antisemitism in Contemporary Political Attitudes.� Political Research Quarterly 78, no. 2 (2025): 619“34.

Mohamed, Besheer. œ25 Years After 9/11, a Portrait of Muslim Americans.� Pew Research Center, September 3, 2026. 

Religion and Voting in the United States

Campbell, David E., Geoffrey C. Layman, John C. Green, and Nathanael G. Sumaktoyo. œPutting Politics First: The Impact of Politics on American Religious and Secular Orientations.� American Journal of Political Science 62, no. 3 (2018): 551-65.  

Deckman, Melissa. œThe Role of White Christian Women Voters in the 2026 Midterms.� PRRI Substack, September 3, 2026.

Deckman, Melissa. œThe Political State of Generation Z.� PRRI Substack, October 30, 2025.

Layman, Geoffrey C., David E. Campbell, and Levi G. Allen. œThe Secular Voter: Secularism and Political Attitudes in the United States.� Political Psychology 46, suppl. 1 (2025): 105“44. 

Smith, Gregory A. œReligious Groups Differ Widely in Their 2026 Midterm Preferences.� Pew Research Center, October 13, 2026. .

Whitehead, Andrew L. œChristian Nationalism and the State of American Democracy in 2026.� Kettering Foundation, October 2, 2026. https://kettering.org/christian-nationalism-and-the-state-of-american-democracy-in-2026/.

Religion and Strengthening Electoral Institutions

Atencio, Mitchell. "'We™d Rather Be Prepared': Faith Leaders Organize Ahead of Tense Midterms." Sojourners, September 30, 2026. 

Buckley, David, Vasu Mohan, and Scott Bledsoe. Sacred Ballots: Engaging with Religious Actors in the Electoral Cycle. White paper. Arlington, VA: International Foundation for Electoral Systems (IFES), June 23, 2023.

Copeland, Stephen. "A Diplomat Journey to Activism." St. Anthony Messenger, November/December 2025.

Franciscan Action Network. "Faith in Democracy." Accessed October 19, 2026. .

Interfaith America. "Faith in Elections Playbook." Updated 2026. .

Stephan, Maria J. "How Catholics Have Defended Free Elections”and Why They Must Do So Again." America Magazine, July 27, 2026.

Religion is one of the central forces shaping the 2026 midterm elections.  shows religious groups dividing in their House preferences: white evangelicals and white Catholics favor Republicans, while Black Protestants, Hispanic Catholics, and unaffiliated voters favor Democrats. Across groups, voters share concerns about the economy and the state of U.S. democracy.

Those differences are playing out on the campaign trail. In Texas, Evangelical Ken Paxton and Presbyterian seminarian James Talarico are both Christian, but appeal to voters through different visions of Christianity. In Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed is making his Muslim faith visible in his campaign, saying in a recent ad that he prays every day and that œwe need a few more people of faith in Washington.� , El-Sayed was asked to disavow the Muslim Brotherhood, an Islamist movement founded in Egypt. El-Sayed said he would, but then challenged the assumption that being Muslim puts his loyalty to the Constitution in doubt. 

On election day itself, religious leaders are mobilizing to strengthen the electoral process. On October 8, 2026, reported on Catholic involvement in the Faiths United to Save Democracy (FUSD) coalition, a national alliance of faith organizations united to use faith to organize peaceful accompaniment at polling places. In 2026, FUSD has hosted virtual training workshops for over one-thousand multi-religious poll chaplains in ˜swing™ states ahead of the November midterm elections. FUSD includes Fransiscan Action Network (FAN), a Fransican social action group led by Michele Dunne, OFS. FUSD coalition includes 321 volunteers associated with the Fransiscan Action Network, whose friars, sisters, and lay members resolve to support œfree, fair, peaceful elections [which] allow for the peaceful resolution of differences.� Outside of polling places, FUSD trainees are encouraged to don their clerical garb to convey peace and reassurance to voters amid concern over partisan confrontations, immigration enforcement operations, and conflicts with election officials at polling sites. The FUSD project comes as the discourse surrounding American elections has been increasingly centered on gerrymandering and the propagation of obstacles to voting access across the nation. In the story from EWTN News, Archbishop Edward Weisenburger of Detroit articulated that in fraught times, Catholics have an obligation to act as stewards of democracy, œDemocracy can be a vehicle for Godʼs care for the human family, but it requires a state that understands its limitations and is not overreaching in its responsibility to create public good order.� 

On October 27, 2026, the Boisi Center for Religion and American Public Life welcomed panelists David Crary, news director of the global religion team at the Associated Press, Melissa Deckman, political scientist and CEO of the Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI), and Michele Dunne OFS, executive director of the Franciscan Action Network (FAN) for an evening discussion with Boisi Center director David Buckley on the November 2026 national midterm elections. The panel, entitled œReligion and the 2026 Midterms: Polarization and Pursuing the Common Good,� discussed shifting voting tendencies in various American faith traditions, the consequences of religion and religiosity on the campaign trail, and the role of faith at polling places.

Religion and Partisanship on the Campaign Trail
Will Ratfi, '27
Undergraduate Research Assistant


Melissa Deckman situated the upcoming election within the longer history of religious and political realignment in the United States. She traced the weakening of the New Deal coalition and the growing association between white Christian voters and the Republican Party, while emphasizing differences across religious groups and generations. She also discussed recent shifts in attitudes toward President Trump and immigration enforcement, most notably among Hispanic Protestants and white evangelical Christians, complicating the idea of a single, stable œreligious vote.� Deckman explained that religion once served as a cross-cutting identity, bringing people with different political affiliations into shared communities. As religious and partisan identities have become more closely aligned, those opportunities have diminished. Her remarks highlighted a central challenge for religious institutions: how to encourage meaningful engagement across political differences when partisan identity increasingly shapes whom people trust and consider part of their community.

Crary brought a journalist perspective to the ways religious identity intersects with political campaigns. He discussed antisemitism, Islamophobia, and disagreements within religious communities, emphasizing the difficulty of representing groups whose members hold varied political views. His observations about divisions among Jewish Americans illustrated why shared religious affiliation should not be taken to imply political agreement. Crary also discussed Catholic bishops who faced backlash for praying with President Trump shortly before the election, raising concerns about when religious engagement can be interpreted as partisan endorsement. Such reactions can make religious leaders hesitant to engage with political figures or enter public debate. His remarks highlighted the difficulty of exercising a public religious role when even prayer can become a source of political controversy.

During the moderated discussion and audience questions, participants returned to whether religion could rise above partisanship and what that would require. Questions about dehumanizing language, perceived victimhood, and political hostility brought attention to how communities speak about those with whom they disagree. The exchange raised the question of how religious communities can maintain their moral commitments while remaining open to disagreement and protecting everyone ability to participate in democratic life.

The panel spoke to the difficulty of sustaining democracy when political opponents seem unwilling to communicate and media coverage amplifies animosity. Discussions of antisemitism and Islamophobia showed how divisions can extend beyond disagreement to questioning whether entire communities belong. The Franciscan Action Network efforts offered a response to these challenges. Building trust, praying with people, and supporting voters demonstrated how religious communities can bridge gaps that undermine confidence in democracy. Protecting democracy requires extending that sense of community to people of other faiths or no faith, so that identity never becomes grounds for dismissing someone concerns or questioning their belonging.

Religion and Grassroots Democracy Protection
Aidan Quealy, '28
Undergraduate Research Assistant

Michele Dunne opened her remarks with a focus on how grassroots, pluralistic religious communities like the Franciscan Action Network encounter the political moment of elections. In her words, œWhat does a faith group do from the ground up?� Dunne cited the January 6, 2021 insurrection at the United States Capitol as an event which deeply scarred public confidence in the peaceful transition of power after elections. In the aftermath, Dunne and FAN centered their electoral mission on exploring œhow [we] can resolve political difference without violence.� As a professed Franciscan, Dunne deployed the ministerial teachings of St. Francis and St. Clare to inspire religious and lay Franciscans to initiate nonviolent intervention in contentious political spaces. Together, Dunne and FAN seek to heal the œwound� which political unrest has dealt to American democratic systems by encouraging members of all faith backgrounds and political ethics to unite in community around a collective stewardship of democratic institutions. Dunne shared how FAN Faith in Democracy Annual Interfaith Prayer Vigil, Election Eve Prayer, and Franciscan Justice circles work on a non-partisan basis with different cross-sections of the public to foster common cause and reverence for democratic systems. 

Specific to the November 2026 midterm elections, Dunne commented on how FAN affiliates as a part of the broader Faiths United to Save Democracy coalition were training as ordained and lay poll chaplains to establish safe environments at polls in battleground states where voter and poll worker intimidation have become concerns. A calm yet reaffirming presence, Dunne spoke about poll chaplains as non-partisan mediators and spiritual companions for all voters who can act as œreliable sources of information in their communities.� Through training seminars on conflict mediation and non-violent, humanizing communication, Dunne hopes that November will yield a œprocedurally boring� midterm election in which both the casting and counting of ballots are presided over with transparency and peaceful intent. 

Michele Dunne contributions spoke to my own uncertainties as a Catholic concerning political action. Her remarks included a mention of an American Catholic tendency of waiting for the hierarchy or local clergy to give Catholics œpermission to speak up� on social issues. This is distinct from the tendencies of mainline Protestants and Evangelicals, who by virtue of their decentralization and colloquial approach may be more politically mobile and responsive. Conversely, Catholic political caution and hesitancy come perhaps as effects of the Church bureaucratic and hierarchical structure, rather than as a specific consequence of any given doctrine or catechism.

Back To Top